Tuesday, October 13, 2009

A Season of....Insensitivty?

Has anyone read Richard Peck's latest, A Season of Giving? I got a copy signed at ALA, but haven't read it yet. A week of back and forth commenting has been going on at SLJ's Heavy Medal Mock Newbery Blog on the meaning, intentions and ramifications of two chapters, specifically.

Don't Throw the Popcorn

The Grinch Who Stole Christmas

Lifting the Veil

Racially Insensitive

Take Two

Please Read the Peck

Wendy asked, "If a book is racially insensitive, does that affect its distinguishedness?" In this day and age, should insensitivity effect award nominations? Thoughts?

1 comment:

Heather said...

I haven't read it yet, so I'll have more detailed commentary later but in general I think that a TON of great children's books are "insensitive" and the really good ones do tackle tough racial and socioeconomic issues. I guess it depends on whether it is gratuitous or not--does it serve an important plot function or character device for the story or is it just put in for shock value? (Like "scrotum"!)